Hold onto your seats, basketball fans, because Rick Pitino is at it again, and this time, he’s shaking things up before the season even begins. But here’s where it gets controversial: after leading St. John’s to a remarkable 31-5 record and a Big East Tournament title last season, Pitino is already making bold moves, like inserting Dillon Mitchell into the starting lineup over the seemingly irreplaceable Bryce Hopkins. Is this a stroke of genius or a risky gamble? Let’s dive in.
Pitino’s ability to motivate and transform teams is nothing short of legendary. Last season, he turned a St. John’s squad with glaring shooting weaknesses into a rebounding and defensive powerhouse. Now, with the addition of the nation’s top-rated transfer group, according to 247sports.com, expectations are sky-high. Ranked No. 5 nationally, this team is being touted as a Final Four contender—but Pitino isn’t resting on laurels. He’s still pushing, prodding, and coaxing every ounce of potential from his players.
At Thursday’s on-campus media day, Pitino dropped a bombshell: Dillon Mitchell would start over Bryce Hopkins, joining Zuby Ejiofor, Osiyah Sellers, Ian Jackson, and Joson Sanon. Hopkins, a 6-7 forward and former All-Big East first-teamer, seemed like a surefire starter after transferring from Providence. And this is the part most people miss: Pitino isn’t just looking for ‘good’ or ‘solid’—he’s demanding greatness and passion. ‘Once he reaches that ‘Mamba’ mentality,’ Pitino said, ‘you’re going to see one of the best players in the country.’ Bold words, but is Hopkins ready to meet that challenge?
Pitino, a seven-time Final Four coach, knows what it takes to reach the pinnacle. He’s not focused on hype; he’s zeroing in on the details—defensive intensity, offensive execution, and a relentless mindset. When asked about Final Four aspirations, he shifted the conversation: ‘These are the things you have to do to be a Final Four contender.’ It’s a masterclass in focus, but it also raises questions: Is this team ready for the pressure?
The players themselves are embracing the challenge. Ejiofor bluntly stated, ‘It’s Final Four or bust,’ acknowledging the urgency with several players facing their final college season. Hopkins, meanwhile, is taking his benching as a wake-up call. ‘I’m willing to do whatever it takes,’ he said, hinting at a deeper hunger to prove himself. With a leaner, more athletic frame and a game that’s ‘slowed down,’ he believes he’s poised for a breakout year.
The road ahead won’t be easy. St. John’s opens with an exhibition against Towson, the preseason favorite to win the Coastal Athletic Association, before facing No. 7 Michigan at Madison Square Garden. Pitino admits he’s prioritizing team development over individual skills, a strategy that could pay dividends—or backfire. ‘We’ll find out more against Michigan,’ he said. ‘Exciting times, but we hope we’re progressing the right way.’
Adding to the intrigue, freshman guard Kelvin Odih returned from a pectoral injury just in time for Thursday’s practice. The 6-4 newcomer, who’s been pushing for playing time since his arrival, downplayed the injury as a ‘strain from overdoing it in the weight room.’ His energy could be a wildcard for a team already brimming with talent.
So, here’s the burning question: Is Pitino’s starting lineup tweak a masterstroke or a misstep? And can this St. John’s team live up to the Final Four hype? Let’s not forget, Pitino has a knack for defying expectations. But in a season where every move is under the microscope, even the smallest decisions could have massive consequences. What do you think? Is Pitino setting his team up for greatness, or is he pushing too hard? Sound off in the comments—this is one debate you won’t want to miss.
